Random Phrase: Taking working from home a little too literally...


Read Me First!

This is the Spode's Abode archive. The old articles and forum have been kept here purely for historical purposes and are no longer updated.

Not all portions of this archive may work as expected.


Please visit the new site.



Athlon 64 Chipset Performance Analysis
Written by Peter Barnard, Spode (02/August/04)
Page 2 of 6

Untitled Document

Chipsets

There are currently three main chipset families on the market.

- nVidia nForce 3
- VIA K8T800
- SiS 755

The simplest chipset to correctly identify is the SiS 755. There are no fancy variants of this chipset at all, just the plain vanilla model.

The VIA K8T800 is also fairly simple. The Pro version gives the added benefits of lockable AGP and PCI Buses, support for 1000MHz HyperTransport and twice the bandwidth between the north bridge and south bridge, increasing the overall bandwidth available to the NIC, PCI slots, and IDE interfaces.

The nForce family is divided into two generations, the 150 and the 250. The 150 has a slower HyperTransport implementation and lacks the ability to lock the AGP and PCI buses. The 250s have AGP and PCI locks, a standard 800MHz HyperTransport implementation and updated SATA support, with some tweaks to the onboard audio as well. The GB versions are exactly the same, but include Gigabit Ethernet support (including their firewall solution). nVidia don't use a separate north/south bridge like VIA and SiS, but instead a single chip. This helps reduce latency and will give faster hard disk performance. The Gigabit NIC is also superior becuase it does not go through the PCI bus and can therefore acheive much closer to true Gigabit speeds.

Before comparing the chipsets performance against each other, it is worth seeing what factors have the most impact on Athlon 64 performance, and why.

Frequencies and Ratios

On an Athlon 64 platform, the FSB only means the speed at which the north bridge core runs. The HyperTransport bus runs at FSB times a certain ratio. On many boards, this ratio can be changed. As usual, the CPU runs at a ratio of the FSB speed, as do the AGP and PCI buses. This means that the HyperTransport Bus can be changed independently of the North Bridge and CPU speeds by simply adjusting the ratio.

The HyperTransport speeds are the first major difference to be found between the various chipsets.

Chipset
Speed (UpStream)
Width (UpStream)
Speed (DownStream)
Width (DownStream)
nForce 3 150
600 MHz
8-Bit
600 MHz
16-Bit
nForce 3 250
800 MHz
16-Bit
800 MHz
16-Bit
K8T800
800 MHz
16-Bit
800 MHz
16-Bit
K8T800 Pro
1000 MHz
16-Bit
1000 MHz
16-Bit
SiS 755
800 MHz
16-Bit
800 MHz
16-Bit

Bandwidth can be calculated using width x frequency. Using this, we can see that a 600MHz 8-Bit solution has the same bandwidth as that of a 300MHz 16-Bit solution, making nVidias solution quite crippled on the bandwidth front. The question is, what difference does this make?


<< Back | 1 | | 2 | | 3 | | 4 | | 5 | | 6 | Next >>



Copyright Andrew Miller
Please read our disclaimer

Search the site:

Random