
Powered by Vanilla 1.1.5a.
Buy iPad online
at PC World.Hey everyone. Got a problem, and I was wondering if anyone here has a similar setup to me, to see if the problem I have maybe a mobo issue.
I got myself an Athlon X2 6000+ to replace my Sempron 3400+. Much snazzier, and worked a charm in my Jetway motherboard (nForce 630A based chipset). Only, whenever the CPU hit 100% or whenever the GPU kicked in for games, a loud whistling noise came out of the machine.
Well, one day the jetway litterally went up in smoke. I thought it was the PSU that had died (Antec Truepower 2.0 550W) so I replaced it with a Hiper Power 630W "Type R", and got an Abit nForce 430 board (for a HTPC, to go with the now unused Sempron). When I plugged the new PSU in, smoke! Checked the mobo, and I can see something on there glowing...
Replaced the mobo with the Abit, and all works again. Same tone occurs when the machine is at 100% CPU or when the GPU kicks in for games.
Since the only components that havn't been changed are the HDD, ram and case - oh, and the GPU, I have to suspect the GPU. But since it didn't happen with the sempron, which sucks a lot less juice, I think that the motherboard isn't quite capable of supplying the juice the Athlon X2 and the 8800 GTS are sucking through it in combination...
Anyone got a similar setup? What motherboard are you using?
Doesn't sound good, and I'm not entirely sure I see that Hiper as an upgrade.
Is it an electronic whistling, or fan related?
Well, the Antec has 2x19A +12v rails, the Hiper has 4x 18A +12v rails. It's why I got it - 1 rail each for ATX, 4pin CPU power connector, and PCI-e 6pin connector, one spare. Technically I should be able to use anything over 400W (according to nVidia's website), so long as there is more than a total of 30A available on +12v. Well, I had 38A, now I have 72A.*
Didn't make the slightest bit of difference, the whining's still there. It's an electronic whine, like a beep that forgets to stop.
*Actually, I doubt the PSU could actually provide 72A across the 4 rails, it's a max of 18A on each individual rail within the total limit of 630W, although I have seen reports that this PSU will run fairly happily well beyond 630W.
From an unfortunate bad batch of Hyper type "R" PSU's a couple of years back when one being tested for a roundup of PSU's by Trusted reviews blew up the expensive test equipment. Since then Hyper have been slated. I have one, my son has one and I have tested the output, Hi-pot and earths in both of them and they are both very good, reasonably accurate, stable on load and did pass all the tests with flying colours.
These are very popular units that not only look good they are as reliable as any other supply at a similar price. My Son had a very expensive Enermax PSU that blew up and destroyed the total sum of parts in his rig. the Hyper he now has has been running near constantly for around two years without any bother and mine works every time I boot the rig it's in.
I guess Spode will not agree with me, but I really wouldn't worry about your Hyper PSU CeeBee.
I have a rig with an ABIT mobo, it has had an 8800GTS in it and all was well. (650 Watt Corsair PSU) I have a horrible feeling the GFX card may be faulty and drawing more current than it should. it was probably a voltage reg that was glowing. do you have any other GFX cards you can try in that mobo?
I think it was a voltage regulator that blew on the Jetway. My current Abit mobo (Abit NF-M2 mATX) has a nVidia chipset, like the jetway did. I don't know if the problem is with nForce boards not having beefy enough power regulation circuits, just these two particular boards, or if the GPU really is sucking up more than it should be.
It didn't have the problem when I ran with the Sempron (havn't tried that since) nor does it happen with the onboard graphics of either mobo.
You're running an Ath64 x2 6000+, aren't you coyote? Or was it a 6400?
One of my rigs is running a 6000+ AM2 dual core CeeBee, it now has an nVidia 8600 GT card in it as I put the GTS in my Intel rig.
It does seem like a GPU problem from the way you describe it. I don't recall anyone having power problems with nVidia chipsets, only some memory compatibility problems. Perhaps it's because it's mATX?
The GTS should have an extra power plug on it that comes directly from the PSU, so that should stop the board regs from being strained. The CPU could be a red herring, but it's worth going back to the Sempron and see what happens.
I think I'm more on Spodes side considering PSUs. My Enermax is solid as a rock, and after I upgraded to it, all of my hardware related issues disappeared and I have never looked back. I now fit Enermax PSUs in all my builds.
I would use more expensive brands such as Seasonic but I don't have that kind of cash.
Coyote - you had the 8800GTS in the AM2 machine alongside the 6000+ at any point? The PCI-e 6pin connector apparantly is only rated to deliver 75W, the rest has to come via the motherboard.
Mike/Spode - the Hiper did have issues with early Type-R's, but every indication is that they fixed them long ago. *really* fixed them - they seem to be stable at 700W, without overheating. And the Antec is also supposed to be a good PSU, the problem happened with that PSU too...
Oh, and here's a pic of what burned on the Jetway... Surrounded by capacitors, I assume this is part of the power regulation circuitry.
Yes CeeBee, as I said earlier I had them both running in an ABIT KN9 ATX mobo, with an nVidia nForce 2 chipset. That's an EVGA 8800GTS overclocked GFX card and an AMD AM2 6000+ dual core CPU. All worked fine for at least six months. I built another Intel based rig and swapped the GTS for a 8600 GT so I could use the GTS in my Intel system. I hope that helps.
That cooked bit on your mobo is a voltage regulator, or rather it was. Usually if that happens, something is drawing far too much current. Occasionally the things just die on their own which could damage other components in the system. I'm still suspecting a faulty graphics card.
Just an addendum - because I really couldn't be bothered to take out the Ath64 and put the Sempron back in, I underclocked the Athlon64. At 2.7Ghz (down from stock of 3.0) it stops beeping as soon as both cores hit 100%, but takes about 30 seconds for the long tone to start. Suggesting something's having to hit a critical temp. It's not the CPU - which is sitting happily at 29C for core 1, and 41c for core2 (at idle) and don't get a chance to heat up any further. (this core temp difference is, apparently, not unusual for someone using an Arctic Cooling Freezer pro 64 - yet another thing I'm gonna have to replace...)
At 2.6Ghz, the beeping stops during the 1 minute CPU stress test. So I fire up CS Source and run the video stress test - beeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeep. 199fps average.
So I drop to 2.5Ghz. Beeeeep beep beeeeeeeeeep beep. 144fps average.
At 2.4Ghz, back to beeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeep. 186fps average. Huh?
At 2.0Ghz, I get occasional beeps during the most stressful parts. 166fps.
I would guess that the tone will disappear altogether at somewhere between 1.9Ghz and 1.5Ghz, from the pattern above (ignoring 2.5Ghz where something screwy is going on). But I'm already at the speed of an Athlon 64 3800+. I'd drop the voltage a little too, but the mobo won't let me go below the stock. Up, yes. Down, nuh-huh. Besides, 1.35v is standard for a 3800+, which means it should be slurping up the exact same amount of juice. No way that a 3800+ is an exotic CPU, and must be sitting in many machines alongside an 8800GTS.
Thoughts? I'm leaning toward faulty GPU...
What's the motherboard's power circuitry like? Apparently the higher power Athlon 64s cause problems on 3- and 4-phase power conversion systems as featured in most cheaper motherboards. Could that potentially be a problem? I've known capacitors to make strange noises when they're about to burst.
'tis worth a thought.
I was thinking on these lines as so many mATX boards are inexpensive, especially as they have built in graphics. It may well be the regulator chain may be weak. CeeBee, do you have to use a n mATX mobo?
Both boards in question are mATX...
I was looking out for a full ATX board actually. I may just splash out on a KN9 or something similar...
How many phases should I be looking for? 6, 8?
If you go for a good quality mobo CeeBee, the regulators will be more than adequate. Abit, ASUS and Asrock are good reliable boards, Get the best you can afford, you may find most of the dearer boards have two PCI e slots for crossfire, don't worry too much about this as you really don't need to use them both. The Abit KN9 is a good solid mobo, not so good for overclocking, but the AMD 6000+ isn't either. Maplin seem to have some, but hunt around the net first
http://www.maplin.co.uk/Module.aspx?C=SO&U=strat340&ModuleNo=97464
The other thing you will find is the proliferation of SATA sockets and only one dual channel IDE socket. This may be enough for your needs, but one hard and one optical drive may not be enough. A new SATA HDD may be useful to load your O/S on and use the IDE for storage. You will find the SATA drives much faster. Seagate seem to be the most voted for these days with Western digital coming second. Avoid Hitachi and Maxstor at the moment as them ain't too good.
Can you test your GTS in another rig to make sure it's OK before you start spending out on mobo's?
Well, my current mobo is an Abit. It's an mATX Abit, but an Abit all the same. I'm not looking to overclock the 6000+, and I don't have any IDE components anymore - everything's SATA (including my DVDRW drive).
I'm considering just dumping the Abit mATX board and 6000+ into a HTPC case spode gave me a few years back, and going Core2 for my personal desktop machine. I'm not sure which way I'll go - I may put the 6000+ on ebay or something. Anyhow, I don't know that many people locally who have a machine I could test the GTS in. It'd have to be something that sucks up a fair bit of juice anyway, because I know that underclocking the 6000+ resolves the problem.
Basically I'm now down to:
A) The Ath64 is sucking up too much juice
B) The 8800 is sucking up too much juice
C) They're both fine, but the mobo doesn't have enough capacity in it's voltage regulators
The best price I could find on the KN9 was £50 plus £8 delivery on ebay. Makes maplin look good - I could pick one up tomorrow...
That board at Maplin is the "S" version, which is slightly better than the standard KN9 I have. It has better heatsinks and it's bound to have bigger/better power regs. I wouldn't sell your 6000+ processor CeeBee, it is actually quite fast, and it does multitask very well. for everyday use it's perfect. (Well, as perfect as you need)
The mobo is really easy to update the bios should you need to. I hope you get it sorted, it's very annoying when a rig doesn't behave!
Try
http://www.ebuyer.com/product/140950
![]()
This motherboard also has DTS Connect (which I've raved about in the past - on the fly digital AC3 encoding...)
Ok, I just installed a KN9S. Default settings, memory timings a little slow (6-6-6-18 @ 800Mhz), CPU at 3Ghz, and it beeps again during startup. And during the CS source video stress test.
Gonna try underclocking it again, but I'm a VERY unhappy bunny right now. This is mobo number 3. Yes, the first one was a Jetway piece of garbage, but the second was a high-end mATX board from Abit, and the 3rd is one Coyote has had the same setup running just fine in.
Just to see if it would help, I've tried using the 8pin PCIe cable (using an 8-6pin PCIe adapter) instead of the 6 pin cable. No change, still beeeeeeeeeeeeping at me.
Time to try the underclock.
*edit* - 2.4Ghz tried, same effect as with the Asus mATX board.
Not a happy bunny.
I really hate to say this CeeBee, but I think your problem is with the 8800 GFX card, I wish you could borrow something to replace it and see what happens. IIRC the memory timings can be easily adjusted in the BIOS on manual setting.
Yeah, the memory timings I can adjust - that's not a problem. The problem is with this damned card.
Maybe I'll try it in my bro's rig next weekend, and see how it works out (or his 9800GTS in my machine).
If your card is faulty CeeBee, I think it might be safer putting your brothers card in your machine, I don't think either of you would be happy if your 8800 damaged his rig! ![]()
I was thinking that - so I'm gonna haul my machine to his place and see if his 9800 makes my machine go all beeepity.
Beep.
Just tried my brother's Inno3D 9800GTS 512MB in the machine, and at 2.4Ghz, 200.23 fps and no beeping in the HL2/CS: Source video stress test. At 3Ghz, 227.31fps and no beeping.
Just plugged in a shredder. Started to shred, and the beeping sound started.
How messed up is this - the beeping sound was coming from my UPS, not my PC!!!
I just ran the stress test again, at 3Ghz. 220.90fps (7 short of my bro's 9800GTX - what's that, 0.3%??? WOW. And his 9800 is overclocked, my 8800 isn't!)
Anyhow, copious amounts of *DOH!* are being eaten over here right now.
LOL!
Beeep. ![]()
1 to 27 of 27